16 March 2021 – by Jennifer Fields
Introduction
Wildfires in the Western United States (US) have been increasing in intensity and destruction over the past decade due to various factors, including severe droughts and heavy winds. They leave undeniable devastation in their wake, such as the charred remains of the forests, farms, and homes they burn as well as the severe health risks posed to the people in their proximity due to smoke and debris.
The fires also cause more latent harm that has lasting effects on communities. Apart from the physical destruction, there are costs that result from the fire evacuations, including the loss of business, personal finances, health struggles, and the impact on deserted communities. Wildfires can create uninhabitable areas, forcing people to evacuate their homes and become migrants in their county or state. The term ‘migrant’ is typically understood to imply crossing country borders. However, the wildfires in Western North America have forced hundreds of thousands of residents in California and Oregon to migrate across county and state lines in search of safety.
I. Physical and Mental Health Effects
The wildfires pose health risks both physically and mentally. Medical complications can begin even before the flames are seen as the smoke alone can be deadly[1]. In October 2020, smoke surrounded counties in Oregon where more than eight million people reside, leading to hundreds of additional Emergency Room visitations. Many of the patients began to struggle with their breathing as soon as the smoke appeared, and hospitals were already stretched thin from battling the COVID-19 pandemic. Some residents were unable to go to hospitals which were at full capacity, and others ended up dying later on from complications such as pneumonia[2]. Minuscule particles invisible to the naked eye mean that the inhalation of smoke is extremely dangerous. Often, people do not realize the risk of their situation until they are already suffering the respiratory effects[3]. The evidence shows that this can be deadly: an unexpected blaze of smoke in California killed 85 people in the summer of 2018, and Stanford University research has revealed that about 3,000 people over the age of 65 in California died prematurely after being exposed to smoke in early August of 2020. [4]
In late October 2020, wildfires spread through southern California, and in an attempt to prevent electrical fires, counties decided to cut the power from homes and buildings[5]. Over 90,000 people were under mandatory evacuation orders in Irving City alone whilst firefighters tried to regain control. Two firefighters were severely injured by the flames and sustained second and third-degree burns across much of their bodies. Enduring such physical trauma also has mental health implications.
Researchers at the Centre of Social Medicine and Community Health in New Delhi, India, carried out a study on trauma and its effects on mental health and found strong links between the two[6]. Disasters such as wildfires are not contained to the inherent damage caused, but create ripples of new problems and intensify the severity of others. Natural disasters have long-lasting traumatic implications for both society at large as well as individuals.
Psychological distress is a common reaction to devastating events such as forced evacuation, relocation, and disruption from the daily routine of one’s life. Experiencing a natural disaster increases the risk of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), anxiety, and depression[7]. Children who may not understand the full severity of the situation are at even greater risk of these mental struggles, as well as suffering from shock as the result of such disruption[8].
As fire season began in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, parents on the West Coast struggled to care for their children’s mental health. It became unsafe to be outside for prolonged periods due to the dangers of smoke inhalation. This left parents inside with their doors locked, windows shut, and air purifiers on trying to keep their children entertained to avoid cabin fever.[9] One mother, Meg Keene, tried to calm her son, who has ADHA, anxiety, and depression. However, the orange skies in the daytime made him afraid of an apocalypse, and he asked to stay in a room without windows[10]. The relentless fires have increased mental health struggles for many families who are trying to survive a global pandemic and wildfire season.
Home is often a secure place for people to bunker down, and with a stay-at-home advisory or orders issued by the governors of Oregon and California, home is where people spent most of their summers. However, complications arose when fire evacuations were ordered whilst these orders were in place. Home was no longer a safe place to be, but neither was anywhere else due to the pandemic. Families struggled to find or afford alternative accommodation following months of layoffs and record unemployment rates. Those who were still employed did not want to risk losing their only income source and disrupt their lives by evacuating. In Oregon, when the fires spread abruptly and destroyed homes, people booked up all the local hotels and accommodation, making alternative housing almost impossible.
Wildfires spread rapidly through Oregon once more in September 2020, and people were forced to begin to evacuate their homes with only three-hours’ notice[11]. Many people were unable to pack within the time restriction and due to the quickly traffic-jammed roads, and so only took their pets and the shirts on their backs. Roads were closed to prevent the spread of fire, but that left few options for people trying to evacuate. With no accommodation available, people parked in parking lots and slept in their cars with their cats and dogs[12]. California and Oregon state governments encouraged inhabitants to prepare and have evacuation plans in place, but with only a few hours’ notice, a pandemic raging and limited resources for the hundreds of thousands of people forced to flee, chaos ensued. Families’ typical evacuation plans, which typically involve staying with a friend or family member in another town were disrupted or not an option due to the risk of COVID-19.
II. Impact on Low-Income Families
Like all disasters, fires disproportionally harm low-income families. Many families out West struggle to afford temporary accommodation elsewhere. Evacuations can happen several times a year and for varying lengths of time. Many people cannot afford to take time off from their jobs and afford housing and food costs elsewhere[13]. Food costs also tend to increase when seeking alternative accommodation, as there is often not a kitchen available. Families are then forced to purchase more expensive premade meals. Often families also do not have reliable transportation or a car, meaning that they must pay bus or train fees; a disruptive cost for an already economically burdened family[14]. Several government agencies provide disaster loans, but unfortunately, not all low-income families qualify for these relief loans[15]. In the event that a family does qualify, it can take months or more for the funds to come through, at which point the family is often even more in debt. In addition, many of these loans do not cover reconstruction for many of the homes that have been damaged or decimated by the heat and the flames of the wildfires.
The 2018 California wildfires burned down Wendy, and Norm Alvarez’s home and tool shed, destroying all their possessions[16]. This left them without shelter and destroyed Norm’s livelihood as he no longer had the tools for his carpentry work. The couple could not afford homeowner’s insurance, which put them in a precarious financial situation. Many of those who lose homes in the fire are unable to fully recover financially, and this has an impact that can last for several generations. It creates instability in the community as people do not know how long they will be able to afford to live in one place, and are often forced to move elsewhere in pursuit of affordable housing options[17]. Well-paying jobs and reasonably priced housing accommodation are difficult to find in rural areas, especially when neighboring communities have suffered similar losses and are competing for the same jobs and homes[18].
Some people have received relief in the form of Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) provided trailers whilst they recover from the disaster, but they may only use the trailer for a maximum of 18 months[19]. Home renovations and repairs are expensive and time-consuming; it takes time to remove all the fire damage and appraise whether anything is at all salvageable. Ellen and John Brackett lost their home in a fire and lived in a FEMA trailer whilst reconstructing their home with the knowledge that they would have to live in a tent on the property if it was not completed in time. As parents of two teenagers and caretakers of a 70-year-old parent, living in a tent would give rise to an entire host of other problems. Many people in the community were already living in tents, with no other relief or rebuilding plans available[20].
III. Impact on Insurance and Business
Due to the risk of fire, insurance companies have significantly increased their rates. This means that many residents cannot afford homeowner or renters’ insurance. In September 2020, California implemented new laws to provide affordable insurance in fire risk areas, but this has created the fear that insurers will simply stop offering insurance to those in high-risk regions[21]. Since 2017, insurers have started to discontinue insurance for homes in fire-prone regions. The inability to access insurance can make homes harder to sell and decreases their overall value[22].
In 2020 California suffered the worst wildfire season recorded. 10,488 structures were damaged or destroyed as a result, and 4,257,863 acres of land and forest were destroyed[23]. This devastation increases the risk that insurers will stop providing services at increasing rates, wrecking the housing market in many areas. Insurance providers have been working with homeowners to detail the steps they can take to mitigate fire risks, but there are only a finite number of precautions a homeowner can take to reduce the risk of damage as forest fires increase in both frequency and severity[24].
Insurance rates and fire risks are also increasing the rate at which people move away from high-risk communities, creating climate migrants within the state. This ruins businesses, especially local businesses that were first plagued by COVID and were then hit by the fires or their secondary effects. Northern California has a billion-dollar agricultural industry that provides over one hundred thousand jobs[25]. Fires in the area have ruined many vineyards and destroyed decades-old vines. Without the plants, there is no business. New vines take three to four years to produce grapes, and much longer to yield quality grapes. The smoke in the area taints the wine while it is being fermented and can ruin the overall flavor, which could become a problem for the industry. Even if plants do survive, the heat of the fires causes much of the fruit fall off, and according to federal food and safety regulations, a crop cannot be sold once it has fallen off of the vine[26]. California grows 90% of avocados in the US – an industry worth millions to the economy – but in 2017 many farmers lost their avocados to wildfires, which led to the loss of many farming jobs as well[27]. Most of these farms are small and family-run in the south of the state. This economic loss has continued to challenge them each year as the fires increase, making it harder to recover each time[28].
The pandemic had already impacted small businesses in rural areas, and the fires and smoke brought with them another wave of problems. Many local shops and cafes were destroyed in the fires, and others had to close due to the hazardous air quality[29]. The sun was blocked out by all the smoke, and indoor seating was limited or banned due to COVID-19 restrictions, leaving countless local business owners with no choice but to close in the interests of safety. This came at a cost for many owners who had to make the difficult choice to close for good. If businesses cannot be run, they must close up shop and move to a place that is inhabitable, where smoke and fire do not pose a threat to them or their customers.
The wildfires have increased in frequency and severity over the past decade, causing millions of dollars of damage and affecting the lives of West Coast communities for generations to come. The fires themselves have wreaked havoc that cannot, without – affordable – insurance, be repaired. Families have suffered emotionally, mentally, and financially from these traumas. Many people have suffered and even died due to health complications from the flames and smoke, whilst others have lost their means of income and life’s possessions. People are being forced to move out of these areas because they can no longer afford the cost associated with living in a high fire risk area.
Conclusion
Despite the tragedies faced by these communities, they have come together and shown strength whilst trying to put their homes and lives back together. Organizations and companies across the US have pitched in to help provide relief.
The Salvation Army has helped provide essential services such as the provision of food, water, shelter, and emotional support to many first responders[30]. Many local Airbnb hosts have volunteered their accommodations, and the American Red Cross has been collecting donations[31].
There are many ways to get involved and help the communities hit by the fires, including volunteering time, resources, and funding. Organizations like Baby2Baby collect essentials such as formula, diapers, wipes, and baby food for infants and toddlers whose families were displaced by the fires[32]. The California Fire Foundation provides families with relief by donating gift cards to assist in replacing necessities that were lost or destroyed[33]. There are also food banks across the West Coast that have reopened and provide meals to families and front-line workers in need. California’s Office of Emergency Services also maintains a list of reputable foundations where donors can safely provide relief funding. When communities support one another, they can accelerate the rebuilding process and minimize the potential ripple effects of such disasters.Â
This article is part of our Spring 2021 collaboration with students from the International Human Rights Clinic at the Western New England University.
Jennifer Fields is a second year Law Student at Western New England School of Law in Springfield, MA. She is on the Dean’s List and is working on a concentration in International and Comparative Law to complement her passion for justice. In college, she worked for Beit Ha’Gefen in Haifa, Israel, creating a safe, multicultural space for refugees settling into Israeli life. Currently, she is active in her community as a trained legal observer for the National Lawyers Guild and does Pro Bono work with the ACLU. When the season is right, she enjoys skiing and spending time on the water.
References
[1] Associated Press, Wildfire smoke in the U.S. exposes millions to hazardous pollution, (Oct. 15th, 2020), https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/wildfire-smoke-us-exposes-millions-hazardous-pollution-rcna156.
[2] Id.
[3] Id.
[4] Id.
[5] David K. Li and Tim Stelloh, California wildfire leaves two firefighters critically injured, forces 90,000 to evacuate, (Oct. 26th , 2020), https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/southern-california-wildfire-forces-60-000-orange-county-residents-evacuate-n1244810.
[6] Nikunj Makwana, Disaster and its Impact on Mental Health, (Oct. 8th, 2019), Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care.
[7] Id.
[8] Id.
[9] Doha Madani, West Coast residents, struggle with psychological burden of repeated evacuations as wildfire seasons worsen, (Nov. 21st, 2020), https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/west-coast-residents-struggle-psychological-burden-repeated-evacuations-wildfire-seasons-n1248451.
[10] Id.
[11] Andrew Freedman, Western wildfires: Evacuations in California and Oregon as destructive fire outbreak engulfs region, (Sept. 9th, 2020),https://www.washingtonpost.com/weather/2020/09/09/western-fires-live-updates/.
[12] Id.
[13] Carlos MartÃn, Improving the Disaster Recovery of Low-Income Families, https://www.urban.org/debates/improving-disaster-recovery-low-income-families
[14] Id.
[15] Id.
[16] Sam Harnett, Low-Income Communities Struggle To Recover After A Wildfire, (Sept. 19th, 2020), https://www.npr.org/2018/09/19/647606049/low-income-communities-struggle-to-recover-after-a-wildfire.
[17] Id.
[18] Id.
[19] Id.
[20] Id.
[21] Christopher Flavelle, As Wildfires Rage, California Presses Insurers to Cut Rates, (Sept. 16th, 2020), https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/16/climate/california-home-insurance-crisis.html.
[22] Id.
[23] https://www.fire.ca.gov/incidents/2020/.
[24] Flavelle, As Wildfires Rage (Sept. 16th, 2020).
[25] Kelly McEvers, Northern California Wildfires Destroy Thousands Of Businesses, All things Considered, NPR https://www.npr.org/2017/10/12/557444669/northern-california-wildfires-destroy-thousands-of-businesses.
[26] BBC, California wildfires: Businesses face ruin as blaze rages, (Dec. 2017), https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-42289831.
[27] Id.
[28] Id.
[29] West Coast Fires will Cost US Dearly, https://www.dw.com/en/economic-impact-california-wildfires-us-west-coast/a-54956210.
[30] Sophie Lewis, How to help victims of the West Coast’s apocalyptic wildfires, (Sept. 11th, 2020), https://www.cbsnews.com/news/wildfires-oregon-california-washington-west-coast-how-to-help-victims/.
[31] Id.
[32] Marie Tae McDermott, How to Help Victims of the California Wildfires, (Oct. 16th, 2020), https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/18/us/help-wildfires-victims.html.
[33] Id.
